How a Young Methodist Minister Became the Best Lawyer in America
In the summer of 2026, Judge Richard Hodge sat down to record his memories of his fascinating legal career. These are the stories of his six decades in the profession: his youth, criminal lawyer, entertainment lawyer, superior-court judge, and private judge.
Most Popular Episodes
Criminal Trials
- The Soledad Seven: The story of seven Black inmates of Soledad prison who were put on trial for murdering a prison guard. Racism, prison gangs, sadistic prison guards, and a corrupt warden flipped what should have been a straighforward trial into a shocking courtroom circus.
- Los Siete de la Raza: The murder of a police officer by a gang of Hispanic youths seemed like an open-and-shut case; his partner gave clear and damning testimony against the youths. But when the defense team questioned the actual witnesses, a completely different story came out, one of lies, police brutality, racism, corruption, and a massive cover-up.
- The Oakland Seven: A story of Vietnam war protests with remarkable parallels to today’s anti-ICE protests. Government lies, police brutality, innocents swept up in the fray ... there are remarkable parallels to today's events and some good lessons.
- The Hells Angels: (Coming soon...) The Hell's Angels had long been a thorn in law-enforcement's side, but when the Angels bombed a law-enforcment official's car, Robert Mueller (then a young prosecutor) decided to take down the Hells Angels organization once and for all. The defense team, including Richard Hodge, had a tough job defending well-known criminals who were quite frank about their lawlessness. The jury's trust was badly eroded when defense revealed briefcases full of cash that were given to informants, but it was prosecutorial overreach ultimately sank the case. As one Angel put it, "Yeah, I'm a criminal, but I didn't do that!"
- Three Tales from the Vietnam Era: A time of massive protests and uprisings against repressive moral codes and drug policies. Three shorter stories: A marijuana smuggler caught red-handed, the student takeover of Moses Hall at Berkeley, and a the best alibi ever for a man falsely accused of assaulting a policeman.
- The Sharpshooter Who Couldn't Shoot Straight: When a backyard barbeque in San Francisco’s Mission District turned into a brawl, the police who responded shot an Army veteran in the butt, claiming he’d fired six shots at them. But somehow, this highly trained expert sharpshooter not only missed the cops from close range, he didn’t even manage to hit the huge double-garage doors behind the cops. Could he be the worst marksman in U.S. Army history?
From the Bench
- A Baby's Death: (Coming Soon) When the body of a newborn infant was found in the marshes of the East Bay, the coroner ruled it a murder. But science isn't always simple, and two teenagers' lives depended on the question: was the baby born alive and abandoned, or was it stillborn?
- A Child's Tragic Shooting: Dixon vs. Beretta: A short story about irresponsible gun ownership. When a young teenager found his father’s loaded Berreta pistol, a friend ended up dead. The bereaved parents brought what could have been a landmark liability case against Berreta, claiming that Berreta had failed to use readily available safety technology. Unfortunately, the gun owner’s attitude made their case unwinnable.
- The Vexatious Litigant: The members of an East-Bay members-only golfer’s club decided one of their members wasn’t a good fit, and they kicked him out. What they didn’t know was that the shunned man was what lawyers call a “vexatious litigant”: He loved to go to court, and he had money. Lots of money. But it turned out the vexatious litigant’s case had a huge hole in it.
- The American River Water Dispute: Coming soon
Musicians and Celebrities
- Page Street, Nightclub: Coming soon
- Steve Miller, Boz Scaggs: Coming soon
Personal Stories
- Jim Jones and the Jonestown Massacre
- Mustard Seeds: Coming soon
- To Kill a Mockingbird: Coming soon
- Prosecutor to Defense: Coming soon
- First Clients: Coming soon
- The Bumbling Burglar: Coming soon

Disarmoring the Prosecution Podcast: